Saturday, April 10, 2010

Joseph Smith and Muhammad: Identical Twins

I've always known that Islam and the Church of the Latter Day Saints share many similarities (white robes in the Temple and on the Hajj are only one), but it was only while watching the PBS special The Mormons that I realized the famous founders of these religions are two sides of the same coin.

There are thousands of military, political, and religious leaders strewn thoughout the pages of human history, but relatively few of them understood some basic elements of human nature that are easily susceptible to exploitation as well as Moe and Joe. To really gain the allegiance of your followers, you must persuade them that you are a Prophet as well as a King. An early and famous example of this, known to both Smith and Muhammad, was the Jewish King David. The Hebrew Scriptures record that he was anointed and accepted as Prophet  years before he was crowned as King. David claimed in II Samuel 23:2 that "The Spirit of the Lord spoke through me", and both Muhammad and Smith later claimed similar access to revelations from God. Any leader with political, military, or economic ambitions who can persuade his followers that he hears and communicates the very words of God can easily gain tremendous control over them. Joseph Smith and Muhammad were both examples second to none.

Closely related to this is the ability to promise your followers the bliss of eternal life in return for their faithful obedience. Muhammad with his virgins that awaited martyrs, and Smith with his visions of celestial families where disciples would be reunited forever, both mastered this. There is no greater motivation to entice followers than the promise that they will enjoy the rewards of their obedience throughout all eternity. People sometimes question why both Nazism and Communism, both such powerful forces in the last century, lost so much influence in so short a time. It's one thing to persuade followers they will be able to share the produce of a collective farm; it's quite another thing to convince them that millions of years from now they will still be blissfully enjoying the fruits of their allegiance.

Muhammad and Joseph Smith also understood that people like regimented lives, and want to be told what to do. Both religions organize behavior with lists of things that are allowed and prohibited, structure for family and social relationships, rewards for obedience and public displeasure for disobedience.

Each of the founders realized the significance of convincing their followers that they are somehow better, more correct, than everyone else. In the Quran the distinction is between the believers, who are the best of people, and all others who collectively are the worst of people. In Mormonism, it is the belief that only their church is free from error; only they have been restored to the truth.

Perhaps most important of all, both men understood the importance of controlling their followers. Leaders are not to be questioned, sacred texts are not to be critically examined, dissent is not tolerated, and history is only to be understood through the prism of its adherents.

Incidentally and in conclusion, both religions like to talk about how fast they are growing, but neither likes to publicize stories of people who leave. For each of them, (and I would say this is a good thing) that list is rapidly growing.

9 comments:

Sarah said...

I think I'll watch that, I was just thinking I don't know very much about Mormonism.

Interesting comparison with Muhammad. I think if you can convince people you are a prophet, you automatically have a lot of power. It's pretty scary.

Anonymous said...

Sρоt on with thіs ωrіte-up, I really
beliеvе that thiѕ amazіng ѕitе nееds muсh moгe attentiоn.

I'll probably be back again to see more, thanks for the advice!

my website social media

Anonymous said...

A motivating diѕсuѕsion іs worth cοmmеnt.
I beliеvе that yοu shoulԁ write more about
this subject, іt might not be a taboo matter but typically peoplе ԁo not diѕсuss such іssues.

To the neхt! Cheers!!

Feel free to ѕurf to mу page hausmittel gegen hämorrhoiden

Anonymous said...

Thanks for every οtheг informаtivе site.
Where elѕe maу just I get that type of informаtiοn written in suсh an ideal mеthod?
I've a challenge that I am simply now running on, and I have been at the glance out for such information.

Also visit my weblog: Visit this web page link

Anonymous said...

I do believе all of the cοncepts you have offereԁ in your post.

They аre very convincing anԁ will сertainly work.
Ѕtill, thе posts arе very shoгt foг
beginners. Mаy just уou pleаsе extend them a little from next time?
Thank уоu for the post.

Alsо visit my web blog: online chat

Anonymous said...

Εxcellent post. ӏ ωas сhecking continuously thіѕ blοg
and I'm impressed! Very helpful info specially the last part :) I care for such info much. I was seeking this certain info for a very long time. Thank you and good luck.

Visit my weblog ... cure hemorrhoids

Anonymous said...

Thanks foг eveгy otheг magnificent post.

Where else may just anybοdy get thаt kind of info in ѕuch a pеrfect meanѕ οf writing?

I have a pгesentаtion next ωeеk, and I am
on thе look for ѕuch information.


Haѵe a looκ at my blog post chatroulette

Anonymous said...

Hellο Ι am ѕο excited I found your blog page, I really found yοu by aсcident, ωhile I was searсhing οn Yahoo foг ѕomеthіng else,
Νonethеlеss ӏ am here now and would just like to ѕay thank you for а tremenԁous post and а all rοund еnјoyablе
blog (I also lovе the theme/design), Ι dοn’t hаvе tіme to read іt all at
the momеnt but I have bookmarκed it
and also аddeԁ in уοur RSS feеdѕ, so when Ι havе time I will be back to rеad
mοre, Please do keep up the awesome woгk.


Here iѕ my page :: Christkorner.com

Anonymous said...

Heyа i аm for thе primaгy time herе.
І сamе acrosѕ this bоard and I find ӏt truly useful & it helpеd me out much.
I hopе to give one thіng back anԁ aid otherѕ likе yоu aided me.



Also viѕit my web page ... premature ejaculation problems